Heat pump vs furnace: which fits your house?
A heat pump usually wins when you heat with electricity, oil or propane, or want cooling too. A high-efficiency gas furnace or a dual-fuel system can make more sense in cold places with cheap gas. Without ducts, look at a ductless mini-split.

On this page
Replacing a heating system is one of the biggest purchases a homeowner makes, and the choice between a heat pump and a furnace is often made in a hurry, in winter, with one contractor's quote. This selector slows that down. It asks four questions about your house and points to the system type that the Department of Energy's guidance favors for that situation, with what to ask before you sign. It does not size equipment or price it; that takes a contractor's load calculation for your house.
Heat pump or furnace?
Answer four questions about your house and climate. You get the system type DOE's guidance points to, what to ask a contractor and what to check first.
Does the house have ducts (supply and return registers in most rooms)?
Radiators, baseboards and wall heaters mean no ducts.
Yes, it has ducts
What heats the house now?
An electric furnace or electric resistance heat
Likely fit
A heat pump
DOE says a modern air-source heat pump can cut the electricity used for heating by up to 75% compared with electric resistance heat such as electric furnaces and baseboards. Your ducts are already there, and the same unit cools in summer.
What to do
- Ask for a heat pump with demand-defrost control, which DOE recommends to cut defrost energy.
- Ask how the backup electric strips are controlled. DOE says strip heat that switches on whenever the thermostat moves a few degrees is one of the most common installation mistakes.
- Hire a technician certified under a program DOE recognizes for heat pump work.
- Ask for more than one written quote, with the equipment's efficiency ratings and a load calculation for your house.
Oil or propane
Do winter temperatures regularly drop below freezing where you live?
Yes, often and for long stretches
Likely fit
A cold climate heat pump
DOE says cold climate heat pumps are designed to perform in temperatures as low as 5°F, and points buyers in places with long freezing spells to ENERGY STAR's Cold Climate label. It heats and cools on electricity alone, through the ducts.
What to do
- Ask the contractor for models that carry the ENERGY STAR Cold Climate label, and for their heating rating (HSPF). In cold climates, DOE says to focus on the highest heating rating you can.
- Ask about the balance point: the outdoor temperature below which backup heat helps. Make sure the backup heat is controlled so it does not run when the heat pump can keep up.
- Seal air leaks and check the insulation first. DOE says homeowners replacing gas heat with a heat pump should weatherize, especially in older homes, and a tighter house needs a smaller system.
- Ask for more than one written quote, with the equipment's efficiency ratings and a load calculation for your house.
Sometimes, or rarely
Likely fit
A heat pump
DOE describes heat pumps as an efficient alternative to furnaces and air conditioners in all climates, and suggests one instead of a separate air conditioner when a house with a furnace adds cooling. One system heats and cools through the ducts you have.
What to do
- In warmer climates, DOE says the cooling rating (SEER) matters more than the heating rating (HSPF). Compare both on the EnergyGuide label.
- Ask for demand-defrost control and a technician certified for heat pump work.
- Seal air leaks and check the insulation first. DOE says homeowners replacing gas heat with a heat pump should weatherize, especially in older homes, and a tighter house needs a smaller system.
- Ask for more than one written quote, with the equipment's efficiency ratings and a load calculation for your house.
Natural gas
Do winter temperatures regularly drop below freezing where you live?
Yes, often and for long stretches
Do you also want central air conditioning, or need to replace an old one?
Yes
Worth comparing
A dual-fuel system, or a cold climate heat pump
With gas, a cold winter and a need for cooling, DOE points to two routes. A dual-fuel (hybrid) system pairs a heat pump for cooling and mild weather with a gas furnace that takes over when it gets cold, using the same ducts. A cold climate heat pump does it all on electricity. Ask for prices on both.
What to do
- Ask each contractor to quote both a dual-fuel system and a cold climate heat pump for the same house.
- Ask what outdoor temperature the dual-fuel system switches to gas at, and how that is set.
- If the furnace is replaced, ask whether the chimney needs a liner. DOE lists that as a common extra when efficiency changes.
- Ask for more than one written quote, with the equipment's efficiency ratings and a load calculation for your house.
No, heating only
Worth comparing
A high-efficiency gas furnace, or a cold climate heat pump
For heating only in a cold climate with gas, DOE says it usually makes sense to invest in the highest-efficiency furnace. High-efficiency condensing furnaces reach 90% to 98.5% AFUE, against 56% to 70% for older ones. A cold climate heat pump is the alternative if you might want cooling later.
What to do
- Ask for a sealed-combustion model, which DOE recommends because it takes outside air for burning and vents straight outdoors.
- Ask whether the chimney or vent needs relining for the new furnace.
- Have the contractor size the furnace after any insulation or air sealing work, so you buy a smaller unit.
- Ask for more than one written quote, with the equipment's efficiency ratings and a load calculation for your house.
Sometimes, or rarely
Do you also want central air conditioning, or need to replace an old one?
Yes
Likely fit
A heat pump
DOE describes heat pumps as an efficient alternative to furnaces and air conditioners in all climates, and suggests one instead of a separate air conditioner when a house with a furnace adds cooling. One system heats and cools through the ducts you have.
What to do
- In warmer climates, DOE says the cooling rating (SEER) matters more than the heating rating (HSPF). Compare both on the EnergyGuide label.
- Ask for demand-defrost control and a technician certified for heat pump work.
- Seal air leaks and check the insulation first. DOE says homeowners replacing gas heat with a heat pump should weatherize, especially in older homes, and a tighter house needs a smaller system.
- Ask for more than one written quote, with the equipment's efficiency ratings and a load calculation for your house.
No, heating only
Worth comparing
Compare a heat pump with a mid- or high-efficiency furnace
In a mild climate with gas and no need for cooling, it is closer. DOE notes that in milder climates the extra cost of going from an 80% to 83% AFUE furnace to a high-efficiency one may be hard to justify, while a heat pump would add cooling you may want later.
What to do
- Ask for quotes on both, with each unit's efficiency rating on the EnergyGuide label.
- Ask your utility for its gas and electric rates, or look up your state's average, so you can compare running costs with the contractor.
- Seal air leaks and check the insulation first. DOE says homeowners replacing gas heat with a heat pump should weatherize, especially in older homes, and a tighter house needs a smaller system.
Nothing yet: it's a new house or addition
Do winter temperatures regularly drop below freezing where you live?
Yes, often and for long stretches
Likely fit
A cold climate heat pump
DOE says cold climate heat pumps are designed to perform in temperatures as low as 5°F, and points buyers in places with long freezing spells to ENERGY STAR's Cold Climate label. It heats and cools on electricity alone, through the ducts.
What to do
- Ask the contractor for models that carry the ENERGY STAR Cold Climate label, and for their heating rating (HSPF). In cold climates, DOE says to focus on the highest heating rating you can.
- Ask about the balance point: the outdoor temperature below which backup heat helps. Make sure the backup heat is controlled so it does not run when the heat pump can keep up.
- Seal air leaks and check the insulation first. DOE says homeowners replacing gas heat with a heat pump should weatherize, especially in older homes, and a tighter house needs a smaller system.
- Ask for more than one written quote, with the equipment's efficiency ratings and a load calculation for your house.
Sometimes, or rarely
Likely fit
A heat pump
DOE describes heat pumps as an efficient alternative to furnaces and air conditioners in all climates, and suggests one instead of a separate air conditioner when a house with a furnace adds cooling. One system heats and cools through the ducts you have.
What to do
- In warmer climates, DOE says the cooling rating (SEER) matters more than the heating rating (HSPF). Compare both on the EnergyGuide label.
- Ask for demand-defrost control and a technician certified for heat pump work.
- Seal air leaks and check the insulation first. DOE says homeowners replacing gas heat with a heat pump should weatherize, especially in older homes, and a tighter house needs a smaller system.
- Ask for more than one written quote, with the equipment's efficiency ratings and a load calculation for your house.
No ducts
Likely fit
A ductless minisplit heat pump
Without ducts, a furnace would need ductwork added. DOE calls ductless minisplit heat pumps an excellent option for houses heated by hot water, radiant panels or space heaters, and for additions where ducts are not feasible. They heat and cool, and each indoor unit has its own thermostat.
What to do
- Many models run up to four indoor units from one outdoor unit, so list the rooms you most need to heat and cool.
- Ask the installer how they sized each indoor unit. DOE warns that oversized or badly placed units short-cycle and waste energy.
- Seal air leaks and check the insulation first. DOE says homeowners replacing gas heat with a heat pump should weatherize, especially in older homes, and a tighter house needs a smaller system.
- Ask for more than one written quote, with the equipment's efficiency ratings and a load calculation for your house.
How the two systems differ
A furnace burns gas, propane or oil, or runs electric heating elements, and blows the warm air through ducts. A heat pump makes no heat of its own. DOE describes it as working like a refrigerator in reverse: it moves heat from the outdoor air into the house in winter and out of the house in summer, so one machine both heats and cools. Since it moves heat instead of making it, a well-installed air-source unit puts out several times as much heat as the electricity it draws, by DOE's account, and can cut the electricity used for heating by up to 75% compared with electric resistance heat such as an electric furnace or baseboards.
Furnace efficiency is measured as AFUE, the share of the fuel's energy that ends up as heat in the house. DOE groups furnaces into older, low-efficiency units at 56% to 70%, mid-efficiency units at 80% to 83% and high-efficiency condensing units at 90% to 98.5%. Heat pumps carry a heating rating (HSPF) and a cooling rating (SEER), both on the yellow EnergyGuide label; DOE introduced stricter versions of both that better reflect real ductwork.
What decides it
Ducts. A ducted heat pump or a furnace both need ducts. Without them, DOE points to ductless minisplit heat pumps, which mount on a wall and need only a small hole to the outdoor unit.
What you heat with now. Coming off electric resistance heat, the case for a heat pump is strongest, for the reason above. Coming off oil or propane, DOE says modern cold climate units now make heat pumps a real option even where winters are long.
Climate. DOE says cold climate heat pumps are designed to keep performing down to 5°F, and points buyers in places with long freezing spells to models carrying ENERGY STAR's Cold Climate label. In cold places with gas, DOE also describes dual-fuel systems: a heat pump for cooling and mild weather, with a gas furnace taking over when it gets cold.
Cooling. If you want air conditioning too, DOE suggests a heat pump instead of adding a separate air conditioner to a furnace.
Before you get quotes
DOE's advice applies to every outcome. Weatherize first: seal air leaks and bring the insulation up to standard, because a tighter house needs a smaller system and DOE says this matters most in older homes. Then have the contractor size the equipment for the house as it will be. For heat pumps, DOE stresses hiring a technician certified for heat pump work and checking that backup electric heat only runs when it is really needed, which it calls one of the most commonly violated installation practices.
Worked example
Maria has a house with ducts, an aging propane furnace and a window air conditioner in the bedroom. She lives where winter nights below freezing are routine. In the selector she answers yes to ducts, oil or propane for fuel, and yes to regular freezing weather. The result is a cold climate heat pump. She asks two contractors to quote ENERGY STAR Cold Climate models with demand-defrost control, asks each how the backup heat is controlled, and books an air sealing visit first so the quotes can size for a tighter house. The same system will replace the bedroom window unit.
Related
The furnace maintenance checklist covers yearly service for the system you have now, and the window, portable or mini-split selector helps if you only need to cool a room or two. Rates differ a lot by state: see electricity rates by state and natural gas rates by state.
Sources
- U.S. Department of Energy, Energy Saver: Heat Pump Systems (archived June 30, 2026) web.archive.org
- U.S. Department of Energy, Energy Saver: Air-Source Heat Pumps (archived June 20, 2026) web.archive.org
- U.S. Department of Energy, Energy Saver: Furnaces and Boilers (archived May 31, 2026) web.archive.org
- U.S. Department of Energy, Energy Saver: Ductless Minisplit Heat Pumps (archived June 18, 2026) web.archive.org
- U.S. Department of Energy, Energy Saver: Central Air Conditioning (archived June 14, 2026) web.archive.org